| Peter captained the first Port Lincoln side in the inaugural carnival, was selected in the E.P. Representative side that year. The Medal for the Carnival Best and Fairest player was appropriately named after Peter Bampton and first presented as such in 1989. |
| Year | Player Name | League |
|---|---|---|
| 1989 | David Carr | Lincoln Districts |
| 1990 | Fabian Davey | Lincoln Districts |
| Anthony Mahar | Far West | |
| 1991 | Ricki Macgowan | Eastern Eyre |
| 1992 | Julian Wait | Great Flinders |
| 1993 | Craig Turner | Kangaroo Island |
| Michael Baldock | Mid West | |
| Stephen Paech | Great Flinders | |
| 1994 | Mark Brown | Eastern Eyre |
| 1995 | Steven Wildman | Eastern Eyre |
| 1996 | Craig Conboy | Mid West |
| 1997 | John Keane | Mid West |
| 1998 | Trevor Johncock | Lincoln Districts |
| 1999 | Gary Hetzel | Great Flinders |
| 2000 | Michael Edwards | Eastern Eyre |
| 2001 | Richard Jones | Lincoln Districts |
| Shaun Evans | Lincoln City | |
| 2002 | Brian Coad | Great Flinders |
| Scott Feltus | Mid West | |
| 2003 | David McPharlin | Lincoln Districts |
| Scott Feltus | Mid West | |
| 2004 | Paul White | Lincoln City |
| 2005 | Scott Feltus | Mid West |
| 2006 | George Pedler | Great Flinders |
| 2007 | Matthew James | Port Lincoln |
| 2008 | Scott Feltus | Mid West |
| 2009 | Matthew Goodwin | Port Lincoln |
| 2010 | Jesse Kemp | Port Lincoln |
| Scott Feltus | Mid West | |
| 2011 | Waylon Johncock | Far West |
| 2012 | Paul White | Port Lincoln |
| 2013 | Nigel James | Great Flinders |
| 2014 | Brad Hazlegrove | Great Flinders |
| 2015 | Jack Kenny | Eastern Eyre |
| 2016 | Tyler Franklin | Eastern Eyre |
| 2017 | Xavier Watson | Great Flinders |
| 2018 | Levi Konitzka | Great Flinders |
| Derek Wanganeen | E.P. Sharks | |
| 2019 | Xavier Watson | Great Flinders |
| Lindsey Thomas | Lincoln Districts | |
| 2020 | COVID-19 | |
| 2021 | Aseri Raikiwasa | Eastern Eyre |
| 2022 | Daniel Minney | Lincoln Districts |
| 2023 | Daniel Minney | Lincoln Districts |