Peter captained the first Port Lincoln side in the inaugural carnival, was selected in the E.P. Representative side that year. The Medal for the Carnival Best and Fairest player was appropriately named after Peter Bampton and first presented as such in 1989.

Year	Player Name	League
1989	David Carr	Lincoln Districts
1990	Fabian Davey	Lincoln Districts
	Anthony Mahar	Far West
1991	Ricki Macgowan	Eastern Eyre
1992	Julian Wait	Great Flinders
1993	Craig Turner	Kangaroo Island
	Michael Baldock	Mid West
	Stephen Paech	Great Flinders
1994	Mark Brown	Eastern Eyre
1995	Steven Wildman	Eastern Eyre
1996	Craig Conboy	Mid West
1997	John Keane	Mid West
1998	Trevor Johncock	Lincoln Districts
1999	Gary Hetzel	Great Flinders
2000	Michael Edwards	Eastern Eyre
2001	Richard Jones	Lincoln Districts
	Shaun Evans	Lincoln City
2002	Brian Coad	Great Flinders
	Scott Feltus	Mid West
2003	David McPharlin	Lincoln Districts
	Scott Feltus	Mid West
2004	Paul White	Lincoln City
2005	Scott Feltus	Mid West
2006	George Pedler	Great Flinders
2007	Matthew James	Port Lincoln
2008	Scott Feltus	Mid West
2009	Matthew Goodwin	Port Lincoln
2010	Jesse Kemp	Port Lincoln
	Scott Feltus	Mid West
2011	Waylon Johncock	Far West
2012	Paul White	Port Lincoln
2013	Nigel James	Great Flinders
2014	Brad Hazlegrove	Great Flinders
2015	Jack Kenny	Eastern Eyre
2016	Tyler Franklin	Eastern Eyre
2017	Xavier Watson	Great Flinders
2018	Levi Konitzka	Great Flinders
	Derek Wanganeen	E.P. Sharks
2019	Xavier Watson	Great Flinders
	Lindsey Thomas	Lincoln Districts
2020	COVID-19
2021	Aseri Raikiwasa	Eastern Eyre
2022	Daniel Minney	Lincoln Districts
2023	Daniel Minney	Lincoln Districts
2024	Jesse Chandler	Western Eyre