| Year | Player Name | League |
|---|---|---|
| 1989 | Chris Prime (8) | Eastern Eyre |
| 1990 | Kenneth Davey (10) | Lincoln Districts |
| Rob Jackamarra (10) | Lincoln City | |
| Michael Dunn (10) | Lincoln City | |
| 1991 | Paul Niekel (7) Neil Phelps (7) | Woomera Great Flinders |
| 1992 | Neil Phelps (11) John Caputo (11) | Great Flinders Woomera |
| 1993 | Leonard Wells (15) | Lincoln Districts |
| 1994 | Rob Jackamarra (15) | Lincoln Districts |
| 1995 | Paul Jenner (6) | Eastern Eyre |
| 1996 | Darren Rule (13) | Great Flinders |
| 1997 | Chris Prime (13) | Eastern Eyre |
| 1998 | Paul Jenner (10) | Eastern Eyre |
| 1999 | Troy Olsen | Mid West |
| 2000 | Troy Olsen (16) | Mid West |
| 2001 | Michael Coad (7) | Great Flinders |
| 2002 | Kieran Glover (12) | Great Flinders |
| 2003 | Steven Wildman (11) | Eastern Eyre |
| 2004 | Darren Bryant (11) | Lincoln City |
| 2005 | Mark Turner (11) | Eastern Eyre |
| Matt Parker (11) | Lincoln Districts | |
| 2006 | Chris Prime | Eastern Eyre |
| 2007 | Chris Prime (12) | Eastern Eyre |
| 2008 | Ross Cambell (13) | Port Lincoln |
| 2009 | Ross Campbell (5) | Port Lincoln |
| 2010 | Matt Parker (7) | Port Lincoln |
| 2011 | Matt Parker (14) | Port Lincoln |
| 2012 | Andrew Frick (12) | Port Lincoln |
| 2013 | Malcolm Miller | Great Flinders |
| 2104 | Joel Fitzgerald | Eastern Eyre |
| 2015 | Luke Harder | EP Sharks |
| 2016 | Johann Wagner (9) | Lincoln City |
| 2017 | Joel Fitzgerald (9) | Eastern Eyre |
| 2018 | Michael Coad (6) | E.P. Sharks |
| 2019 | Lindsey Thomas (10) | Lincoln Districts |
| 2021 | Sid Masters (9) | Eastern Eyre |
